Why 'Broad Tent' Evangelicalism Makes Sense for Global Education

Understanding Evangelical Identity in Global Context - Part 2

When a Pentecostal pastor Emeka from Nigeria first joined a WWES course discussion forum, he was surprised to find himself learning alongside Ms. Nokutenda from Zimbabwe (Anglican), brother Ochieng from Kenya (Presbyterian), and Maria from the Philippines (Methodist). All four identified as evangelical Christians, yet their worship styles, church structures, and even some theological emphases differed significantly. Samuel, coming from a vibrant Pentecostal tradition, initially wondered whether they were studying in the right place.

Three months later, Emeka would write in his course reflection: "I have learned more about the richness of Christ's church in these past months than in years of ministry in my own tradition. We may worship differently, but we share the same Lord, the same gospel, and the same passion for His word. This has made me a better pastor, not a confused one."

Emeka's story illustrates why WWES embraces what we call "broad tent" evangelicalism—an approach that maintains clear theological convictions while welcoming the rich diversity found within the global evangelical movement. But this raises an important question: how can an educational institution maintain theological integrity while embracing such diversity? And why is this approach particularly valuable for theological education in a global context?

The Reality of Global Evangelicalism

To understand why broad tent evangelicalism makes sense, we need to start with a simple observation: evangelicalism today is a genuinely global phenomenon that looks very different from place to place. The typical evangelical Christian worldwide is not a suburban American attending a contemporary service with a praise band. She's more likely to be a woman in the Global South, possibly attending a Pentecostal church, worshiping in her native language, and dealing with challenges that most Western Christians have never faced.

This global reality is reflected in WWES's student body. Our students come from more than 50 countries across Africa, Asia, and beyond. Nearly half identify as Pentecostal, but we also serve Anglicans, Baptists, Presbyterians, Methodists, Lutherans, and members of indigenous church movements. Some worship in elaborate liturgical traditions; others prefer simple, spontaneous gatherings. Some emphasize spiritual gifts and divine healing; others focus on careful biblical exposition and systematic theology.

What unites these diverse students isn't denominational identity or cultural similarity. Instead, they share those core evangelical convictions we discussed in our previous post: the authority of Scripture, the necessity of personal conversion, the centrality of Christ's cross, and the call to active Christian service. These shared convictions create a foundation for meaningful theological education that transcends denominational boundaries.

When Diversity Becomes Strength

Critics sometimes argue that such theological diversity inevitably leads to confusion or compromise. If everyone comes from different traditions, how can you maintain any coherent educational program? This concern assumes that theological education requires uniformity to be effective, but our experience suggests exactly the opposite.

Consider what happened in one recent systematic theology course. Students were discussing the doctrine of sanctification—how Christians grow in holiness after conversion. The Pentecostal students emphasized the Spirit's ongoing work and the possibility of dramatic spiritual breakthroughs. The Reformed students stressed the gradual, lifelong process of growth in grace. The Anglican students brought perspectives on liturgy and sacramental life as means of grace. Rather than creating conflict, these different emphases enriched everyone's understanding.

As one student from Zambia wrote in his final reflection: "I came into this course thinking my tradition had the complete answer to sanctification. I'm leaving with the same core convictions but a much richer understanding of how God works in different ways in different people's lives. This hasn't weakened my faith—it's expanded my vision of God's grace."

This is what happens when diverse Christians gather around shared evangelical convictions: they don't lose their distinctive insights, but they gain appreciation for the larger tapestry of biblical truth. A Presbyterian student doesn't become Pentecostal, but she develops a deeper appreciation for the Spirit's ongoing work. A Pentecostal student doesn't abandon his charismatic convictions, but he gains respect for careful theological reflection and historical wisdom.

The Educational vs. Ecclesiastical Distinction

Part of what makes this broad tent approach work is understanding the difference between educational and ecclesiastical institutions. Churches and denominations necessarily maintain tighter theological boundaries because they're responsible for ordination, church discipline, and doctrinal accountability within specific communities. A Presbyterian seminary training Presbyterian pastors for Presbyterian churches rightly emphasizes Presbyterian distinctives.

But WWES operates as an educational ministry serving the global church rather than a denominational institution serving one tradition. Our students return to their own churches and denominational contexts, where they'll apply their learning within their specific theological frameworks. We're not trying to create a new denomination or blur important theological distinctions. Instead, we're providing biblical and theological education that strengthens Christians within their own traditions while helping them appreciate the broader evangelical movement.

This distinction allows us to focus on what unites evangelical Christians rather than what divides them. In our church history courses, students learn about the development of various Protestant traditions without being asked to choose between them. In biblical studies, they engage with scholarship from across the evangelical spectrum. In practical theology, they consider how gospel principles apply in diverse cultural and denominational contexts.

The Contextual Challenge

Global theological education faces a unique challenge that helps explain why broad tent evangelicalism is not just preferable but necessary. When we train pastors and ministry leaders for service in dozens of different countries and cultural contexts, we can't assume that any single theological tradition has all the answers for every situation.

Take the question of church leadership structures. A student preparing for ministry in a culture with strong traditional authority patterns might benefit from episcopal models that respect established hierarchies. Another student working in a context that emphasizes community decision-making might find congregational approaches more effective. Still another might discover that Presbyterian representative structures best serve their particular situation.

Rather than imposing one model as universally correct, broad tent evangelicalism allows students to learn from multiple traditions while applying biblical principles to their specific contexts. This doesn't mean "anything goes"—all approaches must align with biblical teaching about church leadership. But it does mean recognizing that biblical principles can be faithfully applied in different ways in different contexts.

The same dynamic applies to worship styles, evangelistic methods, social engagement, and countless other ministry questions. The broad tent approach equips students with a rich toolkit of biblical insights and practical wisdom drawn from across the evangelical tradition, then trusts them to apply these resources faithfully in their own contexts.

Learning from Unexpected Sources

One of the most powerful aspects of broad tent evangelicalism in theological education is how it creates opportunities for learning from unexpected sources. Students often discover that Christians from very different backgrounds offer insights that illuminate Scripture in fresh ways.

An African student's understanding of extended family relationships might shed new light on New Testament passages about the church as God's household. A Filipino student's experience with shame-and-honor cultures might offer valuable perspectives on biblical themes of glory and disgrace. A student from a persecution context might read passages about suffering with an immediacy that challenges those from more comfortable circumstances.

These cross-cultural insights don't emerge from abstract multiculturalism but from the shared commitment to biblical authority that characterizes evangelical education. When diverse Christians gather around Scripture with a common conviction that God speaks through His word, they often hear things that Christians from more homogeneous backgrounds might miss.

This dynamic works within denominational diversity as well. Pentecostal students often bring a refreshing emphasis on the Spirit's power that challenges more cerebral traditions to remember that Christianity is not just an intellectual exercise. Anglican students might offer liturgical insights that help contemporary-focused churches appreciate historical wisdom. Baptist students often contribute valuable perspectives on congregational life and individual responsibility.

The Mission Imperative

Ultimately, broad tent evangelicalism makes sense for global theological education because it serves the mission of the church. The Great Commission calls Christians to make disciples of all nations, not just those who share our particular denominational preferences. This mission requires Christians who can work effectively across cultural and denominational boundaries while maintaining clear gospel convictions.

Our students regularly report that their WWES education has equipped them not just for ministry within their own traditions but for collaborative ministry with other evangelical Christians. They've learned to distinguish between core gospel truths that must never be compromised and secondary matters where faithful Christians can disagree. They've developed skills for building bridges across denominational differences while maintaining their own theological convictions.

This preparation proves invaluable in contexts where evangelical Christians from different traditions must work together for common goals—whether in evangelism, social action, theological education, or church planting. Rather than approaching such cooperation with suspicion or confusion, WWES graduates bring both theological clarity and relational wisdom.

The Wisdom of Charitable Orthodoxy

The broad tent approach reflects what might be called "charitable orthodoxy"—firm commitment to essential Christian truths combined with generous recognition that faithful Christians can disagree on secondary matters. This isn't theological relativism that treats all ideas as equally valid. Instead, it's theological wisdom that distinguishes between the gospel core and its various cultural expressions.

This charitable orthodoxy proves particularly valuable in preparing ministry leaders for our complex world. They need deep convictions about what Scripture teaches clearly while developing humility about areas where biblical interpretation requires careful study and legitimate disagreement exists. They need confidence in the gospel's power while remaining teachable about how that gospel applies in diverse cultural contexts.

The stories we hear from our graduates suggest that this balance serves them well. They return to their ministry contexts with strengthened faith, expanded vision, and practical skills for building unity around gospel essentials while navigating diversity in secondary matters. They become bridge-builders rather than boundary-guardians, missionaries rather than separatists.

Pastor Emeka from Nigeria captures this transformation perfectly: "I came to WWES to learn theology. I'm leaving having learned to love the church—not just my corner of it, but the whole gospel-centered family that God is building from every tribe and tongue and nation."

That's the goal of broad tent evangelical education: producing ministry leaders who combine theological conviction with global vision, biblical faithfulness with cultural wisdom, denominational identity with ecumenical charity. In our next post, we'll explore how these principles work out practically in theological study and ministry preparation.

---

Ready to explore the rich diversity of Christian faith and practice? Enroll in our new elective course, "CH-41002 Creeds and Confessions" (available in July 2025).